Review by Choice Review
Doron and Jeffrey's model study of India's garbage problem impressively integrates geography, demography, religion, economics, politics, environmentalism, and the history of sanitation. Clean streets and scientific medicine are new things, little practiced in Europe or the US in the 19th century. An environmental "binding crisis" of plagues or stench has historically been required to jolt politicians into sanitation projects. The British Raj and independent India long recognized that India needed cleaning, but much worked against it. Handling filth was relegated to dalits (untouchables), so higher caste Hindus did not need to worry about it. Mohandas Gandhi disliked cities and ignored their needs. Indian use of night soil lagged behind Japan's and China's. India's population growth, urbanization, and new middle class, however, have vastly outstripped traditional waste handling. Frugal India has two pluses: it is used to recycling and has abundant cheap labor. Several layers of scavengers, collectors (kabaadi), and processors systematically gather and recycle. Elected with the Bharatiya Janata Party in 2014, Prime Minister Modi has made Swachh Bharat (Clean India) a priority. Advanced countries need to think about the waste problem too. Integrates scholarly literature, fieldwork, and interviews. Summing Up: Highly recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty. --Michael G. Roskin, emeritus, Lycoming College
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Choice Review