Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Colombian writer Moreno (1939--1995) makes her English-language debut with a layered if diffuse story of late 1970s Colombia. Lina, an inveterate reader, offers an incisive perspective on the lives of three women, all of whom were former classmates. The sensual Dora marries a brutish, narcissistic medical doctor named Benito Suárez, pointedly named for Mussolini by his Italian mother. Catalina, daughter of a beautiful socialite, is coveted by many, but she marries the secretly gay Alvaro Espinoza, a domineering psychiatrist and sometime provincial governor. Finally, there's Beatriz, who marries Javier, but whose dalliance with would-be revolutionary Victor has drastic consequences. Lina saves Dora from Benito after he attacks her, and Catalina takes revenge on Alvaro by manipulating him into committing suicide. Though the long, convoluted sentences wear on the reader, as does the lack of cohesion, Lina's insights on domineering men are hard to ignore (" seemed to her like those enemies that stalk mankind, like disease and madness, forces that need to be warded off in the name of dignity"). Fans of the Latin American Boom will want to give this a look. (Nov.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Barranquilla, Colombia, may have spawned a legendary group of male writers in the middle of the last century--Gabriel García Márquez included--but young women living there did not enjoy an equally magical time. Moreno, an associate of García Márquez and the famed "Barranquilla Group," delivers a comprehensive indictment of the conditions facing woman in that coastal Colombian city in the 1950s. Related from the point of view of the preternaturally observant Lina, who's looking back on her hometown from an expatriate life in Paris, the novel focuses on the experiences of three young women--Dora, Catalina, and Beatriz--exposing the city's sexual violence, misogyny, classism, and racism in sharp and unrelenting detail. Railroaded or goaded into marriages and relationships that rarely served to benefit their own sexual or financial interests, the three women experience varying degrees of disenchantment or outright self-destruction in the process. Shadowy Lina, whose life experiences seem to echo some of Moreno's own, relates the advice and admonitions dispensed by a chorus of older women, her aunts and a grandmother, who have seen all the harms done by generations of men gone before. Each young woman's story is told with elaborate attention to her history and lineage and those of the men who ensnare and inveigle her into nightmarish alliances. Patience is required to discern the interlocking web of family and professional connections within the provincial city, and the detail with which Moreno traces who wound up where, when, and with whom may be daunting to the casual reader. Translated into English for the first time since the novel's publication in 1987, Moreno's dense and incrementally meandering prose recites a litany of suffering layered upon suffering. Man's inhumanity to (wo)man couldn't be made any clearer. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Review by Kirkus Book Review