Review by Choice Review
Mirsky begins with a brief assessment of Soviet nationality policy, following that with a more extensive discussion of Western theories relating to the ethnic origins of nations, the emergence of nationalism, and the development of the nation-state. The discussion of theory concludes with a categorization of sources and types of ethnic conflict. These concepts are loosely related to the emergence of ethnonationalism in Russia and the Soviet Union. The bulk of the book consists of description and analysis of the role of ethnonationalism in state building and interstate relations in some of the postcommunist states. The book falls short on several counts. The depiction of nationality policy in the Soviet Union is sketchy and adds little to existing knowledge. The discussion of theory is superficial and does not confront the issues in depth. The case studies are incomplete and not well related to the discussion on theory. Several important cases (the Baltic states, Moldova, and Belarus) are excluded without explanation. There is no conclusion in which the author might attempt to draw together his thoughts. The main reason for reading the book is to glean the odd insight into nationality relations from an observer on the scene. Not recommended. D. V. Schwartz; University of Toronto
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Choice Review
