Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
When Randall Hawthorne, a clowning but depressed Vietnam War veteran living in a central Massachusetts city in the early 1980s, commits suicide, he leaves behind a stunned and grieving family-nine-year-old daughter Frankie; her younger brother, Teddy; and their mother, Gerry, a waitress. Frankie, who narrates this wise and often funny first novel about loss and survival (after the collection, A Jeweler's Eye for Flaw), masks her loneliness and pain with the desperate bravura of a precocious but wounded adolescent, mocking her teachers and the school psychologist, drawing obsessively in her sketchbook and dissociating from events in her life by imagining she's a character in a book. But Frankie is too smart and tough to remain isolated forever, and as she proceeds through high school and toward college, she begins to understand the need to connect with others. Most important, she sees how her father's jokes and tall tales were attempts to cover his postwar anguish and to make his children love him. Though Hodgen's sense of the absurd is sometimes overdone and her efforts to capture an adolescent sensibility can err on the side of preciousness, Frankie's vulnerability and resilience make this a moving novel. (May) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Drab first novel, following the story collection A Jeweler's Eye for Flaw (2002). The Hawthornes are a classic dysfunctional family. The father, Randall, is a vet who lost half a leg in Vietnam and lives off his disability checks. The mother, Gerrie, works double shifts at a chain restaurant because, hey, she likes it there. The kids (Frankie is ten, Teddy seven) tag along after their dad as he makes the rounds of the VA hospital, the pool hall and the dog track. In the evening there's television, the glue that holds them together. The story opens in the summer of 1980, as the family situation brightens with the arrival, in their depressed Massachusetts town, of Uncle Harpo, Randall's brother, in full military uniform. His comedy routines are a riot. But he overstays his welcome, and after Gerrie sends him packing, Randall's nightmares get worse and he shoots himself; it's Frankie who finds him dead. The tragedy affects the kids differently. Teddy throws tantrums, but Frankie just shuts down. "A freak and a mute," complains their mother bitterly. Six years later, little has changed for Frankie, now a senior in high school. Her only boyfriend is gone before you know it. She's smart but has no interest in college applications. Teddy is changing (first the class cut-up, later on "just another punk") and Gerrie is changing (finding a boyfriend, a real sweetheart), but Frankie just stays stuck in her rut, even when she's accepted by NYU (her mother had taken care of the application). A closing section has Frankie returning to memories of her father; this last lap around the grief circuit suggests a writer who's run out of material. There's no liftoff for a plotless novel heavy on stereotypes. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Review by Kirkus Book Review