Review by Choice Review
Rodriguez (New America Foundation) has written a concise yet comprehensive insightful history of Mexican Americans, much more extensive than the oversimplified immigration issue that television viewers are exposed to daily. The author begins with Spanish migration to the Americas and subsequent encounter with Natives in Yucatan in 1519, and continues to today's Mexican American population in the US. The book is a serious work, yet not dry history. Anecdotal evidence along with related sources gives the book a distinctly rich character. Rodriguez presents Mexican Americans, too often ignored or erroneously portrayed, in a more positive light. The author points to centuries of acculturation and assimilation. This long experience and a broader, more open, perspective toward race and color should help Americans begin to better understand themselves. The timely topic of race, color, and gender that has been infused into this year's presidential campaign is long overdue as a national discussion. This book is valuable for such a conversation. It includes a treasure trove of footnoted sources for more ambitious readers to discover supplementary materials. Rodriguez undertakes an ambitious task and succeeds brilliantly. From beginning to conclusion, the book is thought-provoking and a delight to read. Summing Up: Essential. All levels/libraries. J. E. Garza University of Texas--Pan American
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
As the largest contingent of the fastest growing minority population in the U.S., Mexican immigrants promise to put an indelible stamp on American culture and notions of race and ethnicity. Mexican scholar Rodriguez examines historical and social factors that have caused the current level of Mexican migration to the U.S. and the greatest contribution of Mexicans, the concept of mestizaje, or racial and cultural synthesis. Mexico's history of conquest and intermixing with the indigenous people has produced a greater tolerance for mixing than has the U.S. history of slavery and stricter definitions of race. Moreover, the evolution of attitudes of Mexican immigrants themselves from desire to be counted as white to advocacy for a broader classification or none at all adds to the more nuanced view of ethnic identity. Rodriguez traces changes in Mexican immigration, fueled by politics and economics in the U.S. and Mexico, and the growing Chicano movement. Rodriguez explores what effect this mestizaje, earned after a long history, though not so tortured as that of the U.S., will have on American culture, racial identity, and minority politics.--Bush, Vanessa Copyright 2007 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Despite its title, this volume from L.A. Times columnist Rodriguez is a thorough and accessible history of Mexico that emphasizes the legacy of mestizaje, mixed races, among Mexico?s inhabitants. Beginning with Cortes? arrival in 1519, an elaborate system of racial classification was put into place to keep separate Spanish and native peoples. The failure of this system, Rodriguez argues, allowed for a more progressive and open-minded approach to race in Mexico compared with, for example, the U.S.: "In colonial New Mexico, mestizaje was the rule rather than the exception." Black/white racial lines were nonexistent, as African natives merged effortlessly into Mexican society (which abolished slavery nearly 40 years before the States). Other developments include the Mexican-American War and subsequent insurgencies in the huge swath of Mexican land ceded to the U.S.; the Mexican revolution and the immigration wave it inspired; the backlash against Mexican-Americans during the depression years; and the Chicano movement of the 1960s and ?70s. There?s more at stake in Rodriguez?s text than the latest immigration hullabaloo (he doesn?t get around to addressing the past 30 years until the last chapter); aside from illuminating a complicated history and deeply contextualizing the present debate, the author takes on the concept of racial classification itself, calling for a change in attitude that more closely reflects the Mexican unifying idea of mestizaje, that we are all, to some extent, racially mixed "mongrels." (Oct. 23) Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Montezuma's revenge is not what you think. Instead, suggests essayist-journalist Rodriguez, the emperor's true revenge may be in the dismantling of the idea of racial differences among white, brown and every other hue. "After the conquest of Mexico," writes the author, "some conquistadors married Indian princesses and daughters of chiefs." So they did, and the Spaniards who came after that first generation of conquistadors married other Indian women, while some Indian men married white women. The result was the mestizo, the Mexican: the race that melded all other races, with "a great variety of phenotypic traits." The upper crust kept itself as white as possible and used skin color as a measure of race and social position. This way of reckoning among whites, creoles, mestizos, indios and other phenotypic types was carried over to the frontier. Once gringo census takers arrived, Californios gave themselves promotions so that, as Rodriguez quotes a historian as remarking, "everyone acquired some fictitious Caucasian ancestry and shed Negro backgrounds--becoming, in effect, lighter as they moved up the social scale." Today, Mexican Americans--who, as Rodriguez points out, constitute two-thirds of the Latino population in the United States--self-identify on the census differently depending on their perceived social status. The upper class considers itself white, but the vast majority of Mexican Americans check "other race," even as most identify ethnically as Hispanic or Latino. As Rodriguez's lucid book demonstrates, now that whites are no longer the majority in California, there is not much talk there of majorities or minorities, even as census officials worry that this confounding of race and ethnicity will "undermine the validity of all the other racial categories." In other words, given the growth of the Latino population and high rate of intermarriage, the "other" will do what its forerunner did, namely subvert and redefine the notion of a melting-pot nation. Of great interest to the demographically inclined, and those who wonder what America will look like at the tricentennial. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Review by Choice Review
Review by Booklist Review
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Review by Kirkus Book Review
