Review by Choice Review
A must-buy for libraries, this book brings together 25 of the world's top Aristotle scholars. Shields's editorial work is superb, and his own contributions are lucid. Classified traditionally into sections on logic, natural explanation, ontology, ethics and politics, and rhetoric, this volume is perfect for an advanced seminar. In most cases, each contributor focuses on the development of Aristotle's argument within a given work, highlighting internal problems and questions. Aristotle's Metaphysics gets a fuller treatment, across five chapters; a useful coda of three chapters, "After Aristotle," focuses on his influence on the philosophy of language and on Arabic and Latin commentators. But the overall goal of this handbook is to serve as an advanced introduction to Aristotle's corpus, not to pursue and defend intertextual constructions and competing contemporary interpretations of Aristotle's theory, development, sources, or influences. It stands in contrast to the four volumes edited by Jonathan Barnes, Malcolm Schofield, and Richard Sorabji, titled Articles on Aristotle (v.1, CH, Sep'76; v.2-4, CH, Mar'80), for example. Many chapters stand out: David Charles's "Teleological Causation," Paul Studtman's "Aristotle's Categorical Scheme," Stephen Menn's broadly probing "Aristotle's Theology," and David Bostock's "Aristotle's Philosophy of Mathematics." Contributors' chapter bibliographies are consistently excellent. Summing Up: Essential. Lower-level undergraduates through researchers/faculty; general readers. P. W. Wakefield Emory University
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Choice Review